Rental Property NOI & Operating Expense Ratio (50% Rule vs Itemized)
The 50% rule is a quick napkin filter, but itemized expense underwriting catches high-tax counties, coastal insurance jumps, and HOA fees before you lock earnest money.
Operating Expense Ratio
OER (%) = (Total Operating Expenses / Effective Gross Income) x 100
Calibration Deals:
DSCR Coverage
1.08x
Below 1.25x
Monthly Cash Flow
+$119
+$1,427/yr
Cap Rate
6.93%
NOI $18,353/yr
70% Flip MAO
$187,500
$77,500 over
Cash-on-Cash
2.06%
Cash In $69,450
1% Rule / GRM
0.92%
GRM 9.0x
Deal Assumptions
$
$
$
$
7x7 Interest Rate vs Vacancy Stress Matrix
4/49 cells pass DSCR >= 1.25xClick any scenario cell to inspect exact monthly cash flow and lender coverage. Emerald cells clear both positive cash flow and your DSCR bar.
| Rate \ Vac | 0% | 3% | 5% | 8% | 10% | 15% | 20% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.50% | |||||||
| 6.00% | |||||||
| 6.50% | |||||||
| 7.00% | |||||||
| 7.50% | |||||||
| 8.00% | |||||||
| 8.50% |
Annual Operating Statement & Debt Service
- Gross Scheduled Income
- $29,400
- Effective Gross Income
- $27,930
- Operating Expenses
- -$9,577
- Net Operating Income
- $18,353
- Monthly Debt (P&I)
- $1,410.44
- Total Cash Required
- $69,450
Educational mathematical modeling worksheet only; not financial, tax, lending, or legal advice.
Reference Scenario Benchmarks
| Scenario | Inputs | Result | Underwriting Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low-Tax Single Family | Taxes 0.9% / No HOA | 36% to 42% OER | Outperforms 50% rule when newer mechanicals exist |
| Older Midwest Duplex | Landlord Water + 10% Maint/CapEx | 46% to 52% OER | Tracks closely to the classic 50% benchmark |
| High-Tax / Coastal Zone | Taxes 2.4% + High Insurance | 55% to 62% OER | 50% rule severely understates true expenses |
Field Verification Checklist
- 1 Exclude mortgage principal and interest from operating expenses; NOI is strictly pre-debt.
- 2 Pull actual county assessor millage rates on the new purchase price rather than the seller historical tax bill.
- 3 Budget both routine maintenance (5%) and long-term CapEx reserves (5% to 8%).