DealSheet

1% Rule vs 2% Rule Rental Screening Breakdown

Quick rent-to-price ratios filter out obvious non-starters in seconds, but high property taxes or HOA dues can turn a 1.1% rule property cash-flow negative.

Rent-to-Price Ratio
Rent Ratio (%) = (Gross Monthly Rent / All-In Purchase Price) x 100
Calibration Deals:
DSCR Coverage
1.24x
Below 1.25x
Monthly Cash Flow
+$314
+$3,766/yr
Cap Rate
7.80%
NOI $19,492/yr
70% Flip MAO
$177,500
$72,500 over
Cash-on-Cash
5.75%
Cash In $65,500
1% Rule / GRM
1.06%
GRM 7.9x

Deal Assumptions

$
$
$
$

7x7 Interest Rate vs Vacancy Stress Matrix

18/49 cells pass DSCR >= 1.25x

Click any scenario cell to inspect exact monthly cash flow and lender coverage. Emerald cells clear both positive cash flow and your DSCR bar.

Rate \ Vac0%3%5%8%10%15%20%
5.35%
5.85%
6.35%
6.85%
7.35%
7.85%
8.35%

Annual Operating Statement & Debt Service

Gross Scheduled Income
$31,800
Effective Gross Income
$30,210
Operating Expenses
-$10,718
Net Operating Income
$19,492
Monthly Debt (P&I)
$1,310.52
Total Cash Required
$65,500

Educational mathematical modeling worksheet only; not financial, tax, lending, or legal advice.

Reference Scenario Benchmarks

Scenario Inputs Result Underwriting Note
0.75% Coastal Growth $400k / $3,000 mo rent 0.75% Ratio Requires appreciation thesis or larger down payment
1.06% Balanced Rental $250k / $2,650 mo rent 1.06% Ratio Often clears positive cash flow near 7% rates
1.45% Duplex Value-Add $240k / $3,500 mo rent 1.46% Ratio Built-in buffer for vacancy and CapEx reserves

Field Verification Checklist

  • 1 Divide monthly rent by total all-in basis (purchase plus rehab), not just contract price.
  • 2 Compare county tax rates before trusting a flat 1% threshold across different states.
  • 3 Use full NOI and DSCR underwriting before submitting a formal purchase offer.

Related Underwriting Guides