Cap Rate vs Cash-on-Cash Return: Exact Underwriting Difference
Cap Rate measures the unlevered yield of the property itself regardless of mortgage terms, while Cash-on-Cash measures the return on your actual out-of-pocket dollars.
Unlevered vs Levered Yield
Cap Rate = NOI / Purchase Price | Cash-on-Cash = (NOI - Debt Service) / Total Cash Invested
Calibration Deals:
DSCR Coverage
1.29x
>= 1.25x Pass
Monthly Cash Flow
+$457
+$5,487/yr
Cap Rate
8.06%
NOI $24,166/yr
70% Flip MAO
$210,500
$89,500 over
Cash-on-Cash
6.94%
Cash In $79,000
1% Rule / GRM
1.05%
GRM 7.9x
Deal Assumptions
$
$
$
$
7x7 Interest Rate vs Vacancy Stress Matrix
23/49 cells pass DSCR >= 1.25xClick any scenario cell to inspect exact monthly cash flow and lender coverage. Emerald cells clear both positive cash flow and your DSCR bar.
| Rate \ Vac | 0% | 3% | 5% | 8% | 10% | 15% | 20% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.25% | |||||||
| 5.75% | |||||||
| 6.25% | |||||||
| 6.75% | |||||||
| 7.25% | |||||||
| 7.75% | |||||||
| 8.25% |
Annual Operating Statement & Debt Service
- Gross Scheduled Income
- $37,800
- Effective Gross Income
- $35,910
- Operating Expenses
- -$11,744
- Net Operating Income
- $24,166
- Monthly Debt (P&I)
- $1,556.64
- Total Cash Required
- $79,000
Educational mathematical modeling worksheet only; not financial, tax, lending, or legal advice.
Reference Scenario Benchmarks
| Scenario | Inputs | Result | Underwriting Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| All-Cash Acquisition | 0% Debt / $300k Cash | Cap Rate == CoC | Without debt, both yields converge identically |
| Positive Leverage | 8.2% Cap / 6.0% Loan | CoC > Cap Rate | Debt constant sits below property Cap Rate |
| Negative Leverage | 6.2% Cap / 7.5% Loan | CoC < Cap Rate | High borrowing rate compresses levered yield |
Field Verification Checklist
- 1 Use Cap Rate to compare two properties apples-to-apples before applying financing.
- 2 Use Cash-on-Cash to evaluate how down payment, interest rate, and rehab dollars affect real equity velocity.
- 3 Watch for negative leverage whenever the mortgage constant exceeds the going-in Cap Rate.